Book Review: Two Can Play That Game by Zakiya N. Jamal
Perfect for women’s sports lovers and for my year of (mostly women’s) sports. It’s a book full of nuanced Black and queer relationships.
Two Can Play That Game by Zakiya N. Jamal

Chelsea has never cared about sports. But when she’s invited to sit courtside at a New York WNBA game, she welcomes the break from her usual routine. What she doesn’t expect is a basketball nearly colliding with her face—or the six-foot-four hottie who jogs over, flashing a heart-stopping grin, to retrieve it.
Adrienne “AD” Daniels is a player on and off the court, notorious for their inability to stay in a relationship. Still, something about Chelsea sticks with them—even though their instant connection can’t bring AD to offer more than one night.
But AD’s agent makes a pitch: Chelsea should pretend to be AD’s girlfriend. It’s a strategic move. AD, hoping to retire after this season, needs to lock down some brand deals—but their identity as a Black, nonbinary lesbian with a messy dating history makes sponsors wary. Chelsea, a sex-positive influencer, is ready to pivot her platform, and this feels like the perfect next step. With Chelsea’s network and AD’s star power, they could both strengthen their public images. Once the season ends, they’ll go their separate ways.
As the ruse starts to work and their connection deepens, Chelsea finds herself on unsteady ground. Falling for AD wasn’t part of the plan, and if she lets herself get too close, she might lose the future she’s finally starting to build.
Thanks to Berkley for the eARC.
Perfect for Women’s Sports Fans
I’ve half-jokingly been calling 2026 my year of sports because I started the year watching a New York Sirens game on January 2nd and following the Winter Olympics and have made it a point to experience a lot of sports-related activities throughout the year. I’ve especially fallen into the world of women’s sports, and as a New York faithful, that of course included going to a few New York Liberty games.
So when I received a request about Two Can Play That Game by Zakiya N. Jamal, I was super excited, despite being in a romance book lull at the moment. The book is a fake dating romance between a sex- and body-positive influencer and a WNBA star, and all of that is exactly right up my alley. This is exactly the kind of sapphic, queer sports romance you think it is!
Balancing Romance, Reality, and Tropes
The book isn’t afraid to tackle the big issues, from transphobia and biphobia to racism, religious trauma, and complicated families. AD, the WNBA star for the “Rebels,” is nonbinary and uses they/them pronouns, and the book really balances the romance elements with the realities that nonbinary and trans athletes (and individuals) face. Similarly, Chelsea, the influencer, grapples with her own issues of having grown up in a religious family, making a name for herself as a sex-positive influencer, and being Black and fat.
At the same time, there were points where I felt like the book could’ve used more room to actually lean into the romance elements. I loved the mix of romance, reality, friendship, and other themes, but at times thought that it could’ve leaned more into the fake dating elements. It’s one of my favorite tropes, and I found this one to be a little less compelling than some of my favorites. Similarly, while there are plenty of sex scenes, I thought they were all quite short and would’ve liked at least one or two that were a bit longer, as one would expect in a typical romance novel. The third act breakup also came at about 90% into the book and was so quickly resolved that I thought it seeped away all the tension out of the plot point. I want to FEEL something when they break up, especially when it’s inevitable fake dating trope where they break up because they catch feelings but get scared and run away.
Still, the book does hit all the right notes and manages to be a breezy, heartfelt read despite the heavy topics.
Other Thoughts
I had a few other small, random thoughts while reading this.
First, it was fun to get some look at the WAGs. I don’t follow the lives of most athletes that much, but you do hear about the men’s basketball and football WAGs. I kind of hadn’t thought of it that much with the WNBA except for perhaps as a joke riffing off of men’s sports, but it makes a lot of sense, and I liked seeing some of the dynamics among the Rebels WAGs. I assume it might also be a means for a potential series – or at least it would in a typical romance book.
Second, I did find something about the writing to be a bit stilted. I think it was the over-use of “thus” and other such words. I don’t typically mind since I think I use words like thus, indeed, etc. more than the average person, but it started feeling a bit unnatural.
Last, it was super funny that all the other team names were actual WNBA team names, except for the Rebels, which are very obviously a stand-in for the Liberty!
Recommendations
- Take a Hint, Dani Brown by Talia Hibbert for my favorite fake dating romance. (My mini review)
- Embrace by Bal Khabra for a romance that also deals with heavy topics. (My review)
- Single Player by Tara Tai, which I admittedly haven’t finished reading, but features another sapphic romance with a nonbinary character.





No Comments